(** Reading a C header, so a binding is checked against the library instead of transcribed from it. [declare-c] closed half the gap: the wrapper, the typedefs and the prototype are generated, so they cannot disagree with each other. The half it left open is the one BUILT.md records as *trusted* — that the signature somebody typed is the function's real signature. Nothing checked it, because no header was ever read. This reads one. {2 Why clang, and why not linked to it} Zig's old [@cImport] ran clang as a *library*. That is precisely the dependency plan.org rejected when it chose text IR over libLLVM bindings: a version-pinned C++ library breaks routinely on upgrade, a binary on PATH does not. So this shells out for [clang -Xclang -ast-dump=json -fsyntax-only], which is the same binary the build already runs for every other purpose and adds no dependency that is not already being paid for. (Zig has since replaced clang here altogether with Aro, a C frontend written in Zig. Their reason was to ship a compiler containing no clang at all, self-contained and cross-compiling anywhere. This project has the opposite premise — [clang] on PATH is the whole toolchain assumption — so that move is explained by a constraint that does not apply here.) {2 What is imported, and what bounds it} Functions, and only functions. Not structs, not enums, not macros. The bound on how much gets imported is not a curated list — it is the package's own [defstruct]s. A C function is imported when every type in its signature maps to something the package already declares or to a machine scalar; a function mentioning a struct the package has not described is refused, by name, with that reason. So [vendor/raylib] describing thirteen structs is what makes the import thirteen structs wide, and describing a fourteenth is what widens it. The layouts stay hand-written and stay the single statement about what raylib's structs are, which is the thing the acceptance tests pin; only the *signatures* come from the header. This is also why no [defstruct] is generated. Generating one would make the header the authority on layout, and then the check below — comparing the package's [defstruct]s against the header's records — would be comparing the header with itself. Keeping the layouts hand-written is what makes [check_structs] an independent second source, and that check is the cheapest real closure of BUILT.md's trusted-not-guaranteed gap: a [_Static_assert] was rejected there as circular for exactly this reason, and this is not circular, because the two sides have different authors. {2 Refusing by demotion} Taken from Zig, and the one decision here most worth keeping. Zig's translator never drops a declaration it cannot handle: [failDecl] emits the name bound to a [@compileError] carrying the reason, so the name still exists, the program still compiles, and asking for that one name fails — at the use site, with the reason. A wholesale import has hundreds of refusals and a caller cares about the one they typed. Flan has that mechanism already: [Load.refuse_hidden] is the same idea, built for [main]. So a refused import becomes a hidden name. [rl/get-gamepad-name] is not a name, and a program that writes it is told *why* — "returns const char *, and a string only crosses as a parameter" — rather than "unknown name". This is also the split the existing generator needs and does not have. [Shim] refuses through [Loc.fail], which is right when a human named one function and wrong for a wholesale import: one returned [const char *] would otherwise kill the whole header. Same judgement, different disposition — a hand-written [declare-c] still hard-fails, and [Shim] is untouched. *) let fail = Loc.fail (* ── Names ───────────────────────────────────────────────────────── The C symbol is kept verbatim in [Ast.DeclareC], so the kebab rule never needs an inverse: the generated wrapper reads the spelling out of the declaration rather than reconstructing it. What the rule does have to be is *injective over one header*, since two C functions arriving under one Flan name is a collision the checker would report as a duplicate declaration about a name nobody wrote. That is asserted below, by name. The rule, in full. A boundary goes before a character that is - an uppercase letter after a lowercase one — [InitWindow] → init-window - an uppercase letter between an uppercase and a lowercase one — [ColorToHSV] → color-to-hsv - a digit after a lowercase letter — [BeginMode2D] → begin-mode-2d and nowhere else; an underscore is a boundary and disappears. The third clause is what keeps [2D] together as one word, and the second is what keeps an acronym together: [SetTargetFPS] is set-target-fps and not set-target-f-p-s, [UnloadUTF8] is unload-utf8. *) let kebab (s : string) : string = let n = String.length s in let b = Buffer.create (n + 8) in String.iteri (fun i c -> let prev = if i > 0 then s.[i - 1] else '\000' in let next = if i + 1 < n then s.[i + 1] else '\000' in let upper c = c >= 'A' && c <= 'Z' in let lower c = c >= 'a' && c <= 'z' in let digit c = c >= '0' && c <= '9' in if i > 0 && prev <> '_' && ((upper c && lower prev) || (upper c && upper prev && lower next) || (digit c && lower prev)) then Buffer.add_char b '-'; if c = '_' then (if Buffer.length b > 0 then Buffer.add_char b '-') else Buffer.add_char b (Char.lowercase_ascii c)) s; Buffer.contents b (* The other direction, and it is deliberately not an inverse of [kebab]. A C *function* never needs one: the symbol is stored verbatim in the declaration. A C *constant* does, because there is no declaration to store it in — a [defenum] member and a [defconst] are Flan names with Flan values and nothing in the source says which enumerator in the header they came from. So the C name has to be reconstructed, and this is the rule: uppercase, and a hyphen becomes an underscore. [left-shift] is [LEFT_SHIFT], [msaa-4x-hint] is [MSAA_4X_HINT]. What it cannot reconstruct is the prefix — raylib's [KEY_], [FLAG_], [GAMEPAD_BUTTON_] — because the Flan name does not contain it. That is declared in the package's [bindings] file rather than guessed, for the reason [read_config] gives about every other guess: a rule that quietly fails to match a name would be worse than no check at all. *) let screaming (s : string) : string = String.map (fun c -> if c = '-' then '_' else Char.uppercase_ascii c) (String.uppercase_ascii s) (* ── What clang was asked, and what it said ────────────────────────── *) (* One C function, as the dump describes it and before anything is decided about whether Flan can hold it. *) type cfn = { csym : string; cret : string; (* the return type, as clang spells it *) cparams : (string * string) list; (* name (possibly ""), type *) cvariadic : bool; cloc : Loc.t; (* the line of the header it is on *) } (* One C struct, for checking a [defstruct] against. *) type crecord = { rname : string; rfields : (string * string) list } type dump = { fns : cfn list; records : crecord list; (* A typedef's underlying spelling: [Texture2D] → [struct Texture], and [Camera] → [Camera3D]. Followed when the spelled name is not one the package declares, which is what lets a Flan [defstruct Texture2D] serve a C parameter typed [Texture]. *) typedefs : (string * string) list; (* The typedef names that are enums rather than records. A C enum is an int on every target this compiles for, which is also what [Shim] lowers a Flan [defenum] to, so the two agree by construction. *) enums : string list; (* Every enumerator in the header, flat: name to value. Flat and not grouped by enum, because raylib's enums are *anonymous* — [typedef enum { FLAG_VSYNC_HINT = 0x40, ... } ConfigFlags;] is an [EnumDecl] with no name at all, and the typedef beside it is a separate node. Keying on the enum's name would find nothing on the corpus this exists for. C puts enumerators in the ordinary namespace at file scope anyway, so the flat table is the one C itself keeps. *) consts : (string * int64) list; } let clang_argv ~header ~flags = [ "clang"; "-Xclang"; "-ast-dump=json"; "-fsyntax-only" ] @ flags @ [ header ] (* clang's stdout, or its stderr if it failed. Run through [Unix.create_process] rather than a shell so a path with a space in it needs no quoting and no [Filename.quote] round trip. *) let run_clang ~loc ~header ~flags = if not (Sys.file_exists header) then fail loc "no such header: %s" header; let argv = clang_argv ~header ~flags in let out_r, out_w = Unix.pipe ~cloexec:false () in let err_r, err_w = Unix.pipe ~cloexec:false () in let pid = try Unix.create_process "clang" (Array.of_list argv) Unix.stdin out_w err_w with Unix.Unix_error _ -> List.iter Unix.close [ out_r; out_w; err_r; err_w ]; fail loc "clang is not on PATH, and reading a C header is done by running it \ (%s)" (String.concat " " argv) in Unix.close out_w; Unix.close err_w; (* Both pipes have to be drained as they fill: the dump is megabytes and a process blocked writing stdout while this waits on its exit is a deadlock that only shows up on a big header. *) let read_all fd = let b = Buffer.create 65536 in let chunk = Bytes.create 65536 in let rec go () = match Unix.read fd chunk 0 65536 with | 0 -> () | k -> Buffer.add_subbytes b chunk 0 k; go () | exception Unix.Unix_error (Unix.EINTR, _, _) -> go () in go (); Buffer.contents b in let out_buf = Buffer.create (1 lsl 21) in let err_buf = Buffer.create 4096 in (* Read stdout first but keep stderr drained too. clang writes very little to stderr for a header that parses, and a header that does not parse writes little enough to fit a pipe, so alternating is not needed — but stdout is the one that is megabytes, so it is the one read in the loop. *) Buffer.add_string out_buf (read_all out_r); Buffer.add_string err_buf (read_all err_r); Unix.close out_r; Unix.close err_r; let status = snd (Unix.waitpid [] pid) in (match status with | Unix.WEXITED 0 -> () | _ -> fail loc "clang could not parse %s:\n%s" header (String.trim (Buffer.contents err_buf))); Buffer.contents out_buf (* ── Reading the dump ──────────────────────────────────────────────── *) (* clang omits [loc.file] when it is the same as the previous node's, so file attribution is a fold over the children in order and not a lookup. Getting this wrong is not loud: it silently imports everything the header includes, or nothing at all. *) let qual j = match Cjson.mem "type" j with Some t -> Cjson.str "qualType" t | None -> None let read_dump ~header (root : Cjson.t) : dump = let want = try Unix.realpath header with Unix.Unix_error _ -> header in let same f = try Unix.realpath f = want with Unix.Unix_error _ -> f = want in let cur = ref "" in let fns = ref [] and records = ref [] and typedefs = ref [] and enums = ref [] in let consts = ref [] in List.iter (fun d -> (match Cjson.mem "loc" d with | Some l -> (match Cjson.str "file" l with Some f -> cur := f | None -> ()) | None -> ()); let mine = same !cur in let name = Cjson.str "name" d in match (Cjson.str "kind" d, name) with | Some "FunctionDecl", Some nm when mine -> (* A [static] or [inline] definition in a header has no symbol to link against from outside the translation unit that has the body. Left out rather than imported and met at the linker. *) let sc = Cjson.str "storageClass" d in if sc <> Some "static" then begin let q = match qual d with Some q -> q | None -> "" in let cret = match String.index_opt q '(' with | Some k -> String.trim (String.sub q 0 k) | None -> q in let cparams = List.filter_map (fun p -> if Cjson.str "kind" p = Some "ParmVarDecl" then Some (Option.value ~default:"" (Cjson.str "name" p), Option.value ~default:"" (qual p)) else None) (Cjson.arr "inner" d) in let line = match Cjson.mem "loc" d with | Some l -> (match Cjson.mem "line" l with | Some (Cjson.Num f) -> int_of_float f | _ -> 0) | None -> 0 in fns := { csym = nm; cret; cparams; cvariadic = Cjson.bool "variadic" d; cloc = Loc.make !cur line 1 } :: !fns end | Some "RecordDecl", Some nm when mine && Cjson.bool "completeDefinition" d -> let rfields = List.filter_map (fun f -> if Cjson.str "kind" f = Some "FieldDecl" then Some (Option.value ~default:"" (Cjson.str "name" f), Option.value ~default:"" (qual f)) else None) (Cjson.arr "inner" d) in (* A bitfield has no address and no Flan spelling; a record holding one is not one this can check, so it is not recorded and the [defstruct] beside it is left unchecked rather than checked wrongly. Same for an unnamed field, which is an anonymous union or struct. *) let ok = List.for_all (fun f -> Cjson.str "kind" f <> Some "FieldDecl" || (not (Cjson.bool "isBitfield" f) && Cjson.str "name" f <> None)) (Cjson.arr "inner" d) in if ok then records := { rname = nm; rfields } :: !records (* An enumerator with no [= n] carries no [ConstantExpr] in the dump at all, so the value has to be counted the way C counts it: one more than the one before, starting at zero. That is not an edge case — raylib's TraceLogLevel writes [LOG_ALL = 0] and then seven bare names, so reading only the explicit ones would check one member of eight and quietly pass the rest. *) | Some "EnumDecl", _ when mine -> let next = ref 0L in List.iter (fun c -> if Cjson.str "kind" c = Some "EnumConstantDecl" then begin (match List.find_map (fun i -> if Cjson.str "kind" i = Some "ConstantExpr" then Cjson.str "value" i else None) (Cjson.arr "inner" c) with | Some v -> (match Int64.of_string_opt v with | Some n -> next := n | None -> ()) | None -> ()); (match Cjson.str "name" c with | Some n -> consts := (n, !next) :: !consts | None -> ()); next := Int64.add !next 1L end) (Cjson.arr "inner" d) | Some "TypedefDecl", Some nm when mine -> (match qual d with | Some u -> typedefs := (nm, u) :: !typedefs; if String.length u > 5 && String.sub u 0 5 = "enum " then enums := nm :: !enums | None -> ()) | _ -> ()) (Cjson.arr "inner" root); { fns = List.rev !fns; records = List.rev !records; typedefs = List.rev !typedefs; enums = List.rev !enums; consts = List.rev !consts } (* ── C types into Flan types ───────────────────────────────────────── *) (* What the package already says exists. The importer adds no type of its own: it either finds a Flan name for a C type here or refuses the function. *) type env = { known_structs : string list; (* the package's defstruct names *) known_enums : string list; (* its defenum names *) d : dump; } exception Refused of string let refuse fmt = Printf.ksprintf (fun m -> raise (Refused m)) fmt let strip_prefix p s = let lp = String.length p in if String.length s >= lp && String.sub s 0 lp = p then Some (String.trim (String.sub s lp (String.length s - lp))) else None (* [const struct Foo] → [Foo]. Qualifiers carry no Flan meaning — Flan has no const — but they have to come off before the name is recognised, and const-ness is read *before* this, where it still means something (see [param_ty]). *) let rec bare s = let s = String.trim s in match List.find_map (fun p -> strip_prefix p s) [ "const "; "volatile "; "restrict "; "struct "; "union "; "enum " ] with | Some s' -> bare s' | None -> s (* A generated type expression carries no location of its own: the thing a message about it wants to point at is the declaration's line in the header, which is what the field and the declaration below carry. *) let ty t = { Ast.t; tloc = Loc.unknown } let rec ty_source (t : Ast.texpr) = match t.Ast.t with | Ast.Tname n -> n | Ast.Tapp (n, args) -> Printf.sprintf "(%s %s)" n (String.concat " " (List.map ty_source args)) | Ast.Tslice e -> Printf.sprintf "[%s]" (ty_source e) | Ast.Tarray (Ast.Lint n, e) -> Printf.sprintf "[%Ld %s]" n (ty_source e) | Ast.Tarray (Ast.Lname n, e) -> Printf.sprintf "[%s %s]" n (ty_source e) | Ast.Tmap (k, v) -> Printf.sprintf "{%s %s}" (ty_source k) (ty_source v) | Ast.Tfn (ps, r) -> Printf.sprintf "(Fn [%s] %s)" (String.concat " " (List.map ty_source ps)) (ty_source r) let tname n = ty (Ast.Tname n) (* The machine scalars, and the ones deliberately left out. [long], [size_t] and the rest are refused rather than guessed, and the reason is specific to this project rather than general fussiness: it builds for x86-64, for wasm32-wasi and for the browser, and [long] is 64 bits on the first and 32 on the others. A guess would be right for the target that gets tested and silently wrong for the two that do not. A header that wants one says so in [declare-c], where a human takes responsibility for it. *) let scalar = function | "void" -> Some "Unit" | "_Bool" | "bool" -> Some "bool" | "char" | "signed char" | "int8_t" -> Some "i8" | "unsigned char" | "uint8_t" -> Some "u8" | "short" | "short int" | "int16_t" -> Some "i16" | "unsigned short" | "unsigned short int" | "uint16_t" -> Some "u16" | "int" | "signed int" | "int32_t" -> Some "i32" | "unsigned" | "unsigned int" | "uint32_t" -> Some "u32" | "int64_t" | "long long" | "long long int" -> Some "i64" | "uint64_t" | "unsigned long long" | "unsigned long long int" -> Some "u64" | "float" -> Some "f32" | "double" -> Some "f64" | _ -> None let width_varies = [ "long"; "long int"; "unsigned long"; "unsigned long int"; "size_t"; "ssize_t"; "ptrdiff_t"; "intptr_t"; "uintptr_t"; "time_t"; "wchar_t" ] (* A named type, after qualifiers and pointers are gone: a struct the package describes, an enum, or nothing this can hold. *) let rec named env (n : string) : Ast.texpr = if List.mem n env.known_structs then tname n else if List.mem n env.known_enums then tname n else if List.mem n env.d.enums then (* A C enum is an int, which is what [Shim] lowers a Flan [defenum] to, so this is the same ABI and not a widening. What it loses is the nice face: a parameter typed [Key] takes [:space] at the call site and an [i32] does not. That is a reason to keep a hand-written [declare-c] for the few calls where it matters, not a reason to refuse the other five hundred. *) tname "i32" else if List.exists (fun r -> r.rname = n) env.d.records then (* Checked before the typedef table, because C's usual idiom [typedef struct Vector3 { ... } Vector3;] puts the same name in both and following it would arrive straight back here. One step first, in the other direction: the package may already describe this record under one of its *other* typedef names. raylib's record is [struct Texture] and [Texture2D], [TextureCubemap] and the package's own [defstruct Texture2D] are all names for it, so [LoadTextureCubemap] returns the same struct the package has described and refusing it would be wrong. Any known struct whose typedef bottoms out at this record will do; they denote the same layout by construction. *) match List.find_opt (fun k -> match List.assoc_opt k env.d.typedefs with | Some u -> String.equal (bare u) n | None -> false) env.known_structs with | Some k -> tname k | None -> refuse "%s is a struct the package does not describe — add a defstruct for \ it, or keep a hand-written declare-c" n else if List.mem_assoc n env.d.typedefs then begin let u = List.assoc n env.d.typedefs in if bare u = n then refuse "%s is a typedef of itself, which is not a type" n else (* Back through [value_ty] and not straight to [named]: a typedef may name a pointer or a function pointer — raylib's [AudioCallback] is one — and only [value_ty] knows what to say about either. Going straight to [named] reported a callback as an unknown type rather than as the callback it is. *) value_ty env u end else if List.mem n width_varies then refuse "%s has a width that differs between this project's own targets (64 \ bits on x86-64, 32 on wasm32), so no single Flan type is right for it" n else refuse "%s is not a type the header importer knows" n (* A type in any position but an outermost parameter. Pointers are where C says least and Flan has to say something: a [T *] is one T, or an array of them, or null, and the header does not distinguish. Flan's [(Ptr T)] claims only "the address of a T", which is the weakest of those and therefore the only honest one — the same judgement Zig makes when it translates [T *] to [[*c]T] rather than to a single-item pointer. *) and value_ty env (s : string) : Ast.texpr = let s = String.trim s in if String.length s > 0 && s.[String.length s - 1] = '*' then begin let inner = String.trim (String.sub s 0 (String.length s - 1)) in let b = bare inner in (* [void *] is an address of unknown element type; [(Ptr u8)] is what the package already spells that as ([Image.data]). *) if b = "void" then ty (Ast.Tapp ("Ptr", [ tname "u8" ])) else ty (Ast.Tapp ("Ptr", [ value_ty env inner ])) end else if String.contains s '[' then refuse "%s is an array, which C passes as a pointer and Flan as a value" s else if String.contains s '(' then refuse "%s is a function pointer, and a C callback is not implemented" s else let b = bare s in match scalar b with | Some "Unit" -> refuse "void is not a value" | Some p -> tname p | None -> named env b (* A parameter, where two C spellings mean things no other position does. [const char *] is a string going in, and [Shim] already knows how to hand one over: Flan's ptr+len, NUL-terminated into a copy for the duration of the call. [char *] without the const is not that. It is very often a buffer the callee *writes*, and handing it a temporary copy would lose the writes with no diagnostic anywhere. const is the only thing in the header that separates the two, so it is what decides, and a genuine out-buffer keeps a hand-written binding that says [(Ptr u8)] and means it. *) let param_ty env (s : string) : Ast.texpr = let s = String.trim s in if String.length s > 0 && s.[String.length s - 1] = '*' then begin let inner = String.trim (String.sub s 0 (String.length s - 1)) in let is_const = strip_prefix "const " inner <> None in match bare inner with | "char" when is_const -> tname "string" | "char" -> refuse "char * is a parameter C may write through, and a Flan string crosses \ as a NUL-terminated copy — the writes would be lost. const char * is \ a string; this one needs a declare-c saying (Ptr u8)" | _ -> value_ty env s end else value_ty env s (* The return type. Every refusal here is one [Shim] would also make; it is made earlier so that the reason names the C spelling rather than the Flan one it was about to become. *) let ret_ty env (s : string) : Ast.texpr option = let s = String.trim s in if bare s = "void" && not (String.contains s '*') then None else if String.length s > 0 && s.[String.length s - 1] = '*' then begin let inner = String.trim (String.sub s 0 (String.length s - 1)) in match bare inner with | "char" -> refuse "returns char *, and a string only crosses as a parameter — a C \ function that returns one returns something Flan has no owner for" | _ -> Some (value_ty env s) end else Some (value_ty env s) (* ── One header, imported ──────────────────────────────────────────── *) type imported = { decls : Ast.decl list; (* Name and reason, for [Load.refuse_hidden]: the name exists as a thing that cannot be had, and asking for it says why. Zig's [failDecl]. *) hidden : (string * string) list; } (* ── The config beside the header ──────────────────────────────────── *) (* Why a config file exists at all, when the importer decides everything else from the header. Because the generated declarations are *committed*. A generated file that is read at build time can be hand-corrected and the correction survives, since nothing rewrites it. A generated file that is checked in is rewritten by the next regeneration, so a hand-edit to it is destroyed without anybody being told — which is the worst shape an edit can have. The edits therefore have to live somewhere regeneration *reads* rather than somewhere it writes, and this is that place. Two directives, which are the two things the header cannot decide: - [exclude], a C symbol or a pattern of them, for what should not be generated at all. - [name], a C symbol and the Flan name it is to take, for where the kebab rule gives something ugly. A postprocessing transform pass over the generated file was the alternative and was rejected: a second program to understand, run over text the generator had already committed to. Both directives here are applied *while* the declarations are made, so the file on disk is already what the config says and nothing reads it twice. *) type config = { excludes : string list; (* C symbol to Flan name. Keyed on the symbol and not on the kebab result, because the symbol is the only spelling that is stable — the whole point of an override is that the kebab result is not what is wanted. *) renames : (string * string) list; (* The three that say how a Flan constant is spelled in C, which is the one thing neither the header nor the Flan source contains. See [screaming] for why it has to be said and [check_constants] for what is done with it. [enum_prefixes]: a [defenum]'s name, and the prefix its members carry in C. [("Key", "KEY_")] checks [left-shift] against [KEY_LEFT_SHIFT]. The prefix ["-"] means the header has nothing to check this enum against and that is deliberate. [const_prefixes]: a prefix of [defconst] names, and the prefix the corresponding C enumerators carry. [("flag-", "FLAG_")] checks [flag-vsync-hint] against [FLAG_VSYNC_HINT]. [constants]: one Flan name, spelled [Enum/member] or as a bare [defconst] name, and the exact C name it answers to. The narrow exception, for the one name a prefix rule gets wrong — raylib's [GESTURE_DOUBLETAP] against a member the package spells [double-tap]. It also brings a name under the check that no prefix rule covers. *) enum_prefixes : (string * string) list; const_prefixes : (string * string) list; constants : (string * string) list; } let no_config = { excludes = []; renames = []; enum_prefixes = []; const_prefixes = []; constants = [] } (* [*] stands for any run of characters and nothing else does anything. Enough for [rl*] or [*Callback], and small enough to read at a glance; a package that needs more than this wants a hand-written declare-c, which it has. *) let matches (pat : string) (s : string) = let np = String.length pat and ns = String.length s in let rec go i j = if i = np then j = ns else if pat.[i] = '*' then let rec from k = (k <= ns && go (i + 1) k) || (k < ns && from (k + 1)) in from j else j < ns && Char.equal pat.[i] s.[j] && go (i + 1) (j + 1) in go 0 0 let excluded cfg sym = List.exists (fun p -> matches p sym) cfg.excludes (* The one place the kebab rule is consulted, so an override is not a special case anywhere below: collisions are computed on the name a function will actually take, which means renaming one of two colliding symbols resolves the collision rather than leaving both refused. *) let flan_name cfg sym = match List.assoc_opt sym cfg.renames with Some n -> n | None -> kebab sym (* The file, in the shape of [headers] and [link] beside it: one directive per line, [#] comments, blank lines ignored. A line that is neither directive is an error rather than a line quietly skipped — the house rule against swallowing things applies to a config as much as to a flag, and a typo in a name override would otherwise show up as a binding under the wrong name. *) let read_config path : config = if not (Sys.file_exists path) then no_config else begin let ch = open_in path in let excludes = ref [] and renames = ref [] in let enum_prefixes = ref [] and const_prefixes = ref [] and constants = ref [] in let rec go n = match input_line ch with | line -> let t = String.trim line in if t <> "" && t.[0] <> '#' then begin let ws = String.split_on_char ' ' t |> List.concat_map (String.split_on_char '\t') |> List.filter (fun w -> w <> "") in match ws with | [ "exclude"; p ] -> excludes := p :: !excludes | [ "name"; sym; flan ] -> renames := (sym, flan) :: !renames | [ "enum"; flan; c ] -> enum_prefixes := (flan, c) :: !enum_prefixes | [ "const"; flan; c ] -> const_prefixes := (flan, c) :: !const_prefixes | [ "constant"; flan; c ] -> constants := (flan, c) :: !constants | _ -> close_in ch; fail (Loc.make path n 0) "a line here is `exclude `, `name `, `enum `, `const \ ` or `constant `, \ and this is neither: %s" t end; go (n + 1) | exception End_of_file -> () in go 1; close_in ch; { excludes = List.rev !excludes; renames = List.rev !renames; enum_prefixes = List.rev !enum_prefixes; const_prefixes = List.rev !const_prefixes; constants = List.rev !constants } end (* [taken] is every name the package already declares, which is what makes the sidecar additive: a hand-written [(declare-c get-gamepad-name ...)] wins over the header, and a C symbol already bound by hand is not bound twice — which [Shim] would refuse for the whole build. [-c] as well as the name itself, because [Shim] generates [foo-c] beside a [foo] whose signature has a struct in it, and a collision there is refused for the whole program rather than for the one binding. *) let of_dump ~env ~taken ~bound_syms ~config (d : dump) : imported = let decls = ref [] and hidden = ref [] in (* Collisions are found before anything is emitted, and they take *every* name in the colliding group down with them. Resolving one by taking the first and refusing the rest is the tempting shape and the wrong one: which C function ends up owning the Flan name would then depend on the order the header happens to declare them in, so moving two lines in somebody else's header silently rebinds a name a Flan program is already calling. There is no reading of [spin-2d] that is obviously right when the header offers both [Spin2D] and [spin2d], so neither gets it, and both say why. The author disambiguates with a hand-written declare-c, which is what that form is for. [bound_syms] is excluded first: a C function the package already binds by hand is not competing for an imported name at all, so it cannot collide with one. *) let candidates = List.filter (fun f -> not (List.mem f.csym bound_syms)) d.fns in (* Excluded before anything else looks at them, so an excluded symbol is not in a collision group either — which is one of the things exclusion is for. It still says why, under the name it would have taken: "there is no such binding" and "the package decided against this binding" are different answers and a reader deserves the second one. *) let dropped, candidates = List.partition (fun f -> excluded config f.csym) candidates in List.iter (fun f -> hidden := (flan_name config f.csym, Printf.sprintf "%s is excluded by the package's binding config, so no \ declaration is generated for it" f.csym) :: !hidden) dropped; let groups = Hashtbl.create 512 in List.iter (fun f -> let k = flan_name config f.csym in Hashtbl.replace groups k (f.csym :: Option.value ~default:[] (Hashtbl.find_opt groups k))) candidates; List.iter (fun f -> let flan = flan_name config f.csym in let skip why = hidden := (flan, why) :: !hidden in match List.rev (Hashtbl.find groups flan) with | _ :: _ :: _ as all -> skip (Printf.sprintf "%s all kebab to %s, and which one got the name would depend on \ the order the header declares them in — so none of them takes \ it. Give the one you want a `name` in the binding config, or \ bind it with a hand-written declare-c" (String.concat ", " all) flan) | _ -> if Hashtbl.mem taken flan || Hashtbl.mem taken (flan ^ "-c") then skip (Printf.sprintf "%s would be the imported name of %s, and the package declares \ %s already" flan f.csym flan) else if f.cvariadic then skip (Printf.sprintf "%s is variadic, and a wrapper cannot forward an argument list \ it does not know the shape of" f.csym) else match (try let ps = List.mapi (fun i (n, t) -> let n = if n = "" then Printf.sprintf "a%d" i else kebab n in { Ast.fname = n; fty = param_ty env t; floc = f.cloc }) f.cparams in (* [void] spelled as the only parameter is C for "none". clang reports it as no ParmVarDecl at all, so this is belt and braces. *) let ps = List.filter (fun (p : Ast.field) -> p.Ast.fname <> "void") ps in Ok (ps, ret_ty env f.cret) with Refused why -> Error why) with | Error why -> skip (Printf.sprintf "%s %s" f.csym why) | Ok (params, ret) -> decls := { Ast.d = Ast.DeclareC ({ Ast.name = flan; params; ret; fbody = []; nloc = f.cloc }, f.csym); dloc = f.cloc } :: !decls) candidates; (* One entry per name. A collision refuses every member of its group and each of them writes the same reason under the same name, which [refuse_hidden] would look up identically but a report would print twice. *) let seen = Hashtbl.create 64 in let hidden = List.filter (fun (n, _) -> if Hashtbl.mem seen n then false else (Hashtbl.add seen n (); true)) (List.rev !hidden) in { decls = List.rev !decls; hidden } (* ── Checking the package's layouts against the header's ───────────── *) (* The point of reading a header that the generator does not otherwise need. BUILT.md rejected a [_Static_assert] on [sizeof]/[offsetof] as circular: both sides would have come from the same field list. This is not circular. The [defstruct] was written by hand and the record comes from the library's own header, so a disagreement is real information — and it is the failure mode the whole FFI is most exposed to, since a permuted [Texture2D] reads as five plausible numbers and no link error. Reported and not raised. A package may legitimately describe a prefix of a struct it only ever holds by pointer, and a header that is a different version of the library is a normal state of affairs to be told about rather than stopped by. *) (* Two rendered Flan types, compared for *representation* rather than for spelling. The one difference that is not a difference is an enum against a 32-bit integer. A Flan [defenum] is an [i32] — that is what [Shim.cty] lowers one to, in a struct field and in a parameter alike — and a C enum is an [int], so the two lay out the same four bytes and differ only in the face they present. Signedness goes with it: raylib spells [IsGestureDetected]'s parameter [unsigned int] and the package calls it [Gesture], and both are four bytes in a register. Symmetric on purpose. The enum may be on either side: the header says [CameraProjection] and the [defstruct] says [i32], or the header says [int] and the [defstruct] says [CameraProjection]. Both are the same statement about four bytes, and reporting either was the bug this closes. What it does *not* accept is anything else. [f64] against the library's [float] is eight bytes where there are four, every field after it moves, and it reads as plausible numbers rather than as a link error — which is the whole reason this check exists. An enum against an [i16], an [i64] or an [f32] is a real disagreement and stays one. *) let enum_like env (t : Ast.texpr) = match t.Ast.t with | Ast.Tname n -> List.mem n env.known_enums | _ -> false let int32_like s = String.equal s "i32" || String.equal s "u32" let agrees env (a : Ast.texpr) (b : Ast.texpr) = let na = ty_source a and nb = ty_source b in String.equal na nb || (enum_like env a && int32_like nb) || (enum_like env b && int32_like na) let check_structs ~env ~(structs : (string * Ast.field list) list) (d : dump) = let record n = match List.find_opt (fun r -> r.rname = n) d.records with | Some r -> Some r | None -> (* [defstruct Texture2D] against a header whose record is [Texture] and whose typedef says so. *) (match List.assoc_opt n d.typedefs with | Some u -> List.find_opt (fun r -> r.rname = bare u) d.records | None -> None) in (* Names and widths both. Order is what a permuted [defstruct] gets wrong and what BUILT.md says only a test can catch; width is the other half of the same hazard and the one it calls out by name — [f64] where the library says [float] lays out eight bytes where there are four, and every field after it moves. Comparing the rendered Flan type rather than the C spelling keeps the two sides commensurable: [u8] and [unsigned char] have to come out equal, and [f32] and [double] have to not. *) let field_mismatch (fs : Ast.field list) (r : crecord) = if List.length fs <> List.length r.rfields then Some (Printf.sprintf "defstruct has %d fields [%s] and %s has %d [%s]" (List.length fs) (String.concat " " (List.map (fun (f : Ast.field) -> f.Ast.fname) fs)) r.rname (List.length r.rfields) (String.concat " " (List.map (fun (n, _) -> kebab n) r.rfields))) else List.find_map (fun ((f : Ast.field), (cn, ct)) -> if kebab cn <> f.Ast.fname then Some (Printf.sprintf "the defstruct has %s where %s has %s, so the field order disagrees" f.Ast.fname r.rname (kebab cn)) else match (try Some (value_ty env ct) with Refused _ -> None) with | None -> None (* a field type this cannot render says nothing *) | Some want -> let a = ty_source want and b = ty_source f.Ast.fty in if agrees env want f.Ast.fty then None else Some (Printf.sprintf "field %s is %s in the defstruct and %s (%s) in %s" f.Ast.fname b a ct r.rname)) (List.combine fs r.rfields) in List.filter_map (fun (n, (fs : Ast.field list)) -> match record n with | None -> None | Some r -> Option.map (fun m -> (n, m)) (field_mismatch fs r)) structs (* ── Checking the package's constants against the header's ─────────── *) (* The half of the claim that was missing, and the one with the worst failure mode. [generate-c] used to say that every [defstruct] and every hand-written [declare-c] agreed with the header, and that claim held. It said nothing about [defconst] or [defenum] — so a wrong flag bit or a wrong enum member was *silent*, which is exactly the class of error the header read exists to catch and the one hardest to see by reading. [FLAG_WINDOW_MINIMIZED] is 0x200; typing 0x100 gives a program that opens a window and hides it, with no diagnostic anywhere and nothing in the source that looks wrong. {2 How a Flan name is turned into a C one} Not by a rule alone. [screaming] reconstructs [LEFT_SHIFT] from [left-shift], but the prefix the C name carries — [KEY_], [FLAG_], [GAMEPAD_BUTTON_] — is nowhere in the Flan source, so it is *declared*, in the package's [bindings] file: {v enum Key KEY_ # (defenum Key [left-shift 340]) vs KEY_LEFT_SHIFT const flag- FLAG_ # (defconst flag-vsync-hint ...) vs FLAG_VSYNC_HINT constant Gesture/double-tap GESTURE_DOUBLETAP # the one the rule misses v} {2 Nothing goes quiet, in either direction} A name the rule builds and the header does not have is *reported* and not skipped. A mapping that silently matched nothing would be worse than no check at all: it would read as coverage and provide none. For the same reason a [defenum] with no [enum] line is itself a finding. Otherwise the silence simply moves up one level — the next lane adds an enum, adds no line, and nothing notices. [enum Foo -] is how a package says out loud that the header has nothing to check [Foo] against; it is a sentence somebody wrote rather than a line nobody did. An [enum] or [const] rule that matches no Flan name at all is a finding too, which is what catches a typo in the rule. [defconst] is *not* held to that. A package's constants are mostly its own — raylib's 26 colours, a screen size — and demanding a line for each would be noise with no second author behind it. A [defconst] is checked when a rule or a [constant] line brings it under the check, and raylib's [gesture-all] is the honest example of one that is not: 1023 is the OR of ten members and no C enumerator has that value to compare against. *) (* Two kinds of finding, and they have different dispositions. [cmapping = false] is a disagreement with the *library*: a value that does not match, or a C name the header does not have. That is the same kind of thing a permuted [defstruct] is, and an ordinary build stops on it. [cmapping = true] is about the package's own [bindings] file — an enum nobody mapped, a rule that reaches nothing. Real, and worth fixing, but it is not the library contradicting anybody, and stopping a build over it would tell a lane that added a [defenum] to go and edit a config file in a message shaped like "your layout is wrong". Those gate [generate-c], which is where the config is being edited and where the author is standing. *) type const_diff = { cname : string; cwhy : string; cmapping : bool } let check_constants ~config ~(enums : (string * (string * int64) list) list) ~(consts : (string * Ast.expr) list) (d : dump) : const_diff list = let found = Hashtbl.create 512 in List.iter (fun (n, v) -> Hashtbl.replace found n v) d.consts; let out = ref [] in let emit mapping name fmt = Printf.ksprintf (fun m -> out := { cname = name; cwhy = m; cmapping = mapping } :: !out) fmt in let say name fmt = emit false name fmt in let mapping_say name fmt = emit true name fmt in (* One Flan name, its value, and the C name it claims to be. *) let compare_one flan v cname = match Hashtbl.find_opt found cname with | None -> say flan "the header has no constant named %s, so nothing here checks %s — \ fix the mapping in `bindings` or the name in the source" cname flan | Some cv -> if not (Int64.equal cv v) then say flan "%s is %Ld here and %s is %Ld in the header" flan v cname cv in let explicit = config.constants in let used = Hashtbl.create 16 in (* Enum members. *) List.iter (fun (ename, members) -> match List.assoc_opt ename config.enum_prefixes with | None -> mapping_say ename "the defenum %s has no `enum` line in the package's `bindings`, so \ nothing checks its members against the header — add `enum %s \ `, or `enum %s -` to say the header has nothing to \ check it against" ename ename ename | Some "-" -> Hashtbl.replace used ("enum:" ^ ename) () | Some prefix -> Hashtbl.replace used ("enum:" ^ ename) (); List.iter (fun (m, v) -> let flan = ename ^ "/" ^ m in let cname = match List.assoc_opt flan explicit with | Some c -> c | None -> prefix ^ screaming m in compare_one flan v cname) members) enums; (* Plain constants, and only the ones a rule or a [constant] line reaches. *) let int_of (e : Ast.expr) = match e.Ast.e with Ast.Int v -> Some v | _ -> None in List.iter (fun (n, e) -> (* The prefix is marked as reaching something *before* an explicit [constant] line is consulted, so a rule whose every match is also spelled out by hand is not reported as reaching nothing. A false finding in a check whose whole value is that a finding is real. *) let by_rule = List.find_map (fun (fp, cp) -> match strip_prefix fp n with | Some rest -> Hashtbl.replace used ("const:" ^ fp) (); Some (cp ^ screaming rest) | None -> None) config.const_prefixes in let cname = match List.assoc_opt n explicit with Some c -> Some c | None -> by_rule in match cname with | None -> () | Some cname -> (match int_of e with | Some v -> compare_one n v cname | None -> say n "%s is mapped to %s but its value is not a plain integer, so \ there is nothing to compare" n cname)) consts; (* A rule that reaches nothing. A typo in a prefix would otherwise read as coverage and provide none, which is the failure this whole section is about. *) List.iter (fun (ename, _) -> if not (Hashtbl.mem used ("enum:" ^ ename)) then mapping_say ename "`enum %s` in the package's `bindings` names no defenum the \ package declares" ename) config.enum_prefixes; List.iter (fun (fp, _) -> if not (Hashtbl.mem used ("const:" ^ fp)) then mapping_say fp "`const %s` in the package's `bindings` matches no defconst the \ package declares" fp) config.const_prefixes; (* And a [constant] line naming nothing. *) List.iter (fun (flan, _) -> let known = List.mem_assoc flan consts || List.exists (fun (ename, members) -> List.exists (fun (m, _) -> String.equal (ename ^ "/" ^ m) flan) members) enums in if not known then mapping_say flan "`constant %s` in the package's `bindings` names no defconst and no \ enum member the package declares" flan) explicit; List.rev !out (* ── The entry point ───────────────────────────────────────────────── *) let dump_of_clang ~loc ~header ~flags = let text = run_clang ~loc ~header ~flags in let json = try Cjson.parse text with Cjson.Bad m -> fail loc "clang's AST dump of %s did not parse: %s" header m in read_dump ~header json (* ── The caches, two of them ───────────────────────────────────────── *) (* Measured, not assumed: reading raylib.h costs 64ms — 30ms for clang to write 1.8 MB of JSON and the rest to parse it and map it — against an 8ms check for the whole program without it. The dev loop rebuilds constantly and the header does not change between two of those rebuilds, so paying it every time is eight times the cost of everything else put together. What is cached is the *extracted* dump and not clang's JSON: it is the parse that is half the cost, and what comes out is a few hundred signatures rather than megabytes of source ranges. Keyed the way the object cache is keyed, and for the same reason — on everything that could change the answer. The header's path, its size and mtime, and the full flag list, because a flag changes what clang sees; plus a format version, because the cached value is a marshalled OCaml value and a compiler whose [dump] type has changed must not read one written by the old one. [Marshal] does not check that for you and a mismatch is a segfault rather than an exception, so the discipline is: **change the [dump] type, bump [cache_format] in the same commit.** Nothing enforces it. It lives under the object cache directory, beside the [.o] files, because it is the same kind of thing: derived from an input the compiler did not write, stable across builds, and safe to delete. One directory to clear rather than two. *) let cache_format = 2 (* The same directory [Build.cachedir] makes, spelled here rather than called: [Load] is upstream of this file and downstream of [Reach], so reaching [Build] from here closes a cycle. Two lines that have to agree, and the consequence of their disagreeing is a second cache directory rather than a wrong answer. *) let cachedir () = let d = Filename.concat (Filename.get_temp_dir_name ()) "flan-objcache" in (try Unix.mkdir d 0o700 with Unix.Unix_error (Unix.EEXIST, _, _) -> ()); d let dump_of_disk ~loc ~header ~flags = let st = try Some (Unix.stat header) with Unix.Unix_error _ -> None in match st with | None -> dump_of_clang ~loc ~header ~flags | Some st -> let key = Digest.to_hex (Digest.string (String.concat "\000" [ string_of_int cache_format; (try Unix.realpath header with Unix.Unix_error _ -> header); string_of_int st.Unix.st_size; Printf.sprintf "%.6f" st.Unix.st_mtime; String.concat " " flags ])) in let path = Filename.concat (cachedir ()) (key ^ ".dump") in let cached = if not (Sys.file_exists path) then None else try let ch = open_in_bin path in Fun.protect ~finally:(fun () -> close_in_noerr ch) (fun () -> Some (Marshal.from_channel ch : dump)) with _ -> (* A truncated or stale file is not worth a build failure: the header is right there and can be read again. *) (try Sys.remove path with Sys_error _ -> ()); None in (match cached with | Some d -> d | None -> let d = dump_of_clang ~loc ~header ~flags in (* Written to a distinct name and renamed, so two builds running at once cannot see a half-written file — the object cache does the same. *) (try let tmp = Printf.sprintf "%s.%d.tmp" path (Unix.getpid ()) in let ch = open_out_bin tmp in Fun.protect ~finally:(fun () -> close_out_noerr ch) (fun () -> Marshal.to_channel ch d []); Sys.rename tmp path with Sys_error _ -> ()); d) (* And in front of that file, the session's own copy — which is the level that matters for the dev loop, because the daemon is a process that lives for as long as the editor does and re-reads the file once per evaluation that imports the package again. Reading the cached dump is 0.33ms and extracting the declarations from it is another 3.3ms, so this is small; it is here because *nothing* is the right amount for a long-lived process to pay twice for an answer it already has. **Keyed on the header's path and the flags, and deliberately not on its mtime.** That is the whole of the mid-session question: a header edited while a session is running is not re-read, and the session keeps the signatures it started with until it is restarted. It is the same rule a changed [.c] file follows — the daemon compiled the package's C once, at startup, and a redefinition does not recompile it — and the same rule the running program itself follows, since its layouts are the ones it was built with. The alternative is worse in both directions: keying on mtime would put a [stat] on a path that is supposed to cost nothing, and it would let a header change take effect on the next [C-c C-c] in a *program that is still running with the old layouts*, which is precisely the silent disagreement the header check exists to prevent. A new session reads the new header, and the disk cache above keys on mtime so it does not serve it the old one. Two tables rather than one, because the two answers have different inputs. The *dump* is the header's alone, so a second package importing the same header shares it. The *declarations* are the dump read against one package — which names it already has taken, which structs and enums it knows, which C symbols it binds by hand — so they are keyed on those too, and a package whose decls an evaluation has added to gets its declarations worked out again rather than served an answer about the decls it used to have. *) let dumps : (string, dump) Hashtbl.t = Hashtbl.create 4 let imports : (string, imported * dump * env) Hashtbl.t = Hashtbl.create 4 let header_key ~header ~flags = String.concat "\000" ((try Unix.realpath header with Unix.Unix_error _ -> header) :: flags) let dump_of ~loc ~header ~flags = let k = header_key ~header ~flags in match Hashtbl.find_opt dumps k with | Some d -> d | None -> let d = dump_of_disk ~loc ~header ~flags in Hashtbl.replace dumps k d; d let env_of ~known_structs ~known_enums d = { known_structs; known_enums; d } let header ~loc ~header:h ~flags ~known_structs ~known_enums ~taken ~bound_syms ~config = let k = (* Sorted, because neither the taken table nor the declaration order is a fact about the package — two loads of the same file that enumerate them differently are the same question and must not miss each other. *) let sorted xs = List.sort compare xs in String.concat "\000" (header_key ~header:h ~flags :: "\001" :: sorted known_structs @ ("\001" :: sorted known_enums) @ ("\001" :: sorted (Hashtbl.fold (fun n () acc -> n :: acc) taken [])) @ ("\001" :: sorted bound_syms) (* The config is part of the question: two loads that disagree about what is excluded or renamed are different questions, and serving one the other's answer is the bug this key exists to prevent. *) @ ("\001" :: sorted config.excludes) @ ("\001" :: sorted (List.map (fun (a, b) -> a ^ "=" ^ b) config.renames)) @ ("\001" :: sorted (List.map (fun (a, b) -> a ^ "=" ^ b) config.enum_prefixes)) @ ("\001" :: sorted (List.map (fun (a, b) -> a ^ "=" ^ b) config.const_prefixes)) @ ("\001" :: sorted (List.map (fun (a, b) -> a ^ "=" ^ b) config.constants))) in match Hashtbl.find_opt imports k with | Some r -> r | None -> let d = dump_of ~loc ~header:h ~flags in let env = env_of ~known_structs ~known_enums d in let r = (of_dump ~env ~taken ~bound_syms ~config d, d, env) in Hashtbl.replace imports k r; r (* ── Printing a declaration back as source ─────────────────────────── *) (* Which makes the third option in DISCUSS.md item 6 available at no extra cost: generate the declarations from the header, *commit the result*, and regenerate when the library moves. That trade — explicit in the source, checked against reality, no header read at build time — is a real one, and it needs a printer and nothing else. [flan import-c] is it. *) let decl_source (d : Ast.decl) = match d.Ast.d with | Ast.DeclareC (fn, csym) -> Printf.sprintf "(declare-c %s [%s]%s %S)" fn.Ast.name (String.concat " " (List.map (fun (p : Ast.field) -> Printf.sprintf "%s %s" p.Ast.fname (ty_source p.Ast.fty)) fn.Ast.params)) (match fn.Ast.ret with None -> "" | Some t -> " " ^ ty_source t) csym | _ -> "" (* ── A hand-written binding, against the header's own signature ────── *) (* The other half of closing the trusted gap, and the one that pays off immediately: [vendor/raylib] carries 176 [declare-c] lines that were transcribed by hand from raylib's documentation, and until now nothing could say whether any of them was right. This says so, one at a time. Compared as *rendered Flan types*, not as C spellings, because the two sides are not written in the same language and only the Flan rendering is commensurable. Three differences are expected and are not reported: - the Flan name. [IsKeyPressed] is [key-pressed?] by hand and [is-key-pressed] by rule, and the hand-written one is better. The C symbol is what identifies the function here, not the name. - an enum parameter. The header says [KeyboardKey] and the importer has no way to know the package calls that [Key], so it says [i32]; the hand-written [Key] is the same int with a better face. - a [(Ptr T)] where the header says [T *] and the hand-written line chose something more specific for a reason it recorded. What is left after those is a real disagreement about a width, an arity or a direction — which is exactly the class of bug BUILT.md warns about, where [f64] against the library's [float] reads as garbage rather than as a link error. *) type sig_diff = { dsym : string; dflan : string; dwhy : string } let diff_bound ~env ~(bound : (Ast.fn * string) list) (d : dump) = let by_sym = Hashtbl.create 512 in List.iter (fun f -> Hashtbl.replace by_sym f.csym f) d.fns; List.filter_map (fun ((fn : Ast.fn), csym) -> match Hashtbl.find_opt by_sym csym with | None -> Some { dsym = csym; dflan = fn.Ast.name; dwhy = "the header does not declare this function at all" } | Some c -> let say why = Some { dsym = csym; dflan = fn.Ast.name; dwhy = why } in (* [agrees] above is the whole of it: an enum against a 32-bit integer is the expected difference and not a finding, and an enum against anything else still is one. *) let norm (t : Ast.texpr) = ty_source t in let same a b = agrees env a b in if c.cvariadic then None else if List.length fn.Ast.params <> List.length c.cparams then say (Printf.sprintf "declared with %d parameters and the header says %d (%s)" (List.length fn.Ast.params) (List.length c.cparams) (String.concat ", " (List.map snd c.cparams))) else let param_diff = List.find_map (fun ((p : Ast.field), (_, ct)) -> match (try Some (param_ty env ct) with Refused _ -> None) with | None -> None | Some want -> if same want p.Ast.fty then None else Some (Printf.sprintf "parameter %s is %s and the header says %s (%s)" p.Ast.fname (ty_source p.Ast.fty) (norm want) ct)) (List.combine fn.Ast.params c.cparams) in match param_diff with | Some why -> say why | None -> (match (try Ok (ret_ty env c.cret) with Refused w -> Error w) with | Error _ -> None | Ok want -> let agrees = match (want, fn.Ast.ret) with | None, None -> true | Some a, Some b -> same a b | _ -> false in if agrees then None else say (Printf.sprintf "returns %s and the header says %s (%s)" (match fn.Ast.ret with None -> "nothing" | Some t -> ty_source t) (match want with None -> "nothing" | Some t -> ty_source t) c.cret))) bound (* ── Regenerating the committed declarations ───────────────────────── *) (* Generate once, commit the result, regenerate when the library moves. What that buys is in DISCUSS.md item 6 and it is not caching — the dump is already cached on disk and in memory, so a build that reads the header pays for it once either way. It is that no header is needed by *anybody*: the declarations are in the repository, so they are greppable, they diff when raylib moves, and a build needs libraylib linkable and nothing else. The opt-in that used to decide whether a package had 172 bindings or 428 stops deciding anything. What it costs is the check. A header read at build time compared every hand-written declaration against the library on every build; a committed file compares nothing, because a file on disk has no second opinion. That check is not decoration — it verified all 172 hand-written declarations and all 16 struct layouts against raylib 5.5 and found them exactly right, and against a 5.1-dev header on the same machine it found ten real differences. So regeneration runs it, and the check *gates the write*. There is no way to ask for new declarations without comparing the package against the header they come from, because the one function that writes the file is this one and it refuses when the two disagree. A regeneration that quietly rewrote the bindings against a header the library does not match would produce exactly the failure BUILT.md warns about — a permuted struct read as five plausible numbers rather than as a link error — and it would produce it in a committed file that looks reviewed. The hand-written declarations are what make the signature half of that check mean anything, which is why they stay. Everything the generator emits agrees with the header by construction, so diffing generated output against the header it came from is a tautology; the hand-written lines were transcribed from raylib's documentation by a person, so they are an independent second opinion and the only thing here that the header can actually contradict. *) type regen = { gwrote : bool; gdecls : int; gfns : int; ghidden : (string * string) list; gstructs : (string * string) list; gsigs : sig_diff list; gconsts : const_diff list; } let banner h = Printf.sprintf ";;;; Generated from %s by `flan generate-c`. Do not edit this file.\n\ ;;;;\n\ ;;;; Every line here was read out of the C header named by `headers`, and\n\ ;;;; the next regeneration overwrites the file — so a correction made here\n\ ;;;; is destroyed without anybody being told. Corrections go in `bindings`\n\ ;;;; beside it, which is read *while* these lines are made: `exclude` drops\n\ ;;;; a function, `name` gives one a Flan name the kebab rule would not.\n\ ;;;; Anything neither directive can express is a hand-written declare-c in\n\ ;;;; the package's own .flan, which wins over this file and is left alone.\n\ ;;;;\n\ ;;;; Regenerating compares the package against the header first and\n\ ;;;; refuses to write when they disagree, so this file and the\n\ ;;;; hand-written declarations beside it agreed with %s when it was made.\n\n" (Filename.basename h) (Filename.basename h) (* [ds] is the package's *hand-written* declarations: every .flan in the directory except the one being written. Reading the output back in would make regeneration idempotent in the worst way — every symbol would already be bound, so the second run would generate nothing and cheerfully write an empty file. *) let regenerate ~loc ~header:h ~flags ~(ds : Ast.decl list) ~config ~out = let taken = Hashtbl.create 64 in List.iter (fun d -> match Ast.declared_name d with | Some n -> Hashtbl.replace taken n () | None -> ()) ds; let pick f = List.filter_map f ds in let structs = pick (fun (d : Ast.decl) -> match d.Ast.d with Ast.Defstruct (n, fs) -> Some (n, fs) | _ -> None) and enums = pick (fun (d : Ast.decl) -> match d.Ast.d with Ast.Defenum (n, ms) -> Some (n, ms) | _ -> None) and pconsts = pick (fun (d : Ast.decl) -> match d.Ast.d with Ast.Defconst (n, _, e) -> Some (n, e) | _ -> None) and bound_syms = pick (fun (d : Ast.decl) -> match d.Ast.d with | Ast.Declare (_, s) | Ast.DeclareC (_, s) -> Some s | _ -> None) and bound = pick (fun (d : Ast.decl) -> match d.Ast.d with Ast.DeclareC (fn, s) -> Some (fn, s) | _ -> None) in let imported, dump, env = header ~loc ~header:h ~flags ~known_structs:(List.map fst structs) ~known_enums:(List.map fst enums) ~taken ~bound_syms ~config in let gstructs = check_structs ~env ~structs dump in let gsigs = diff_bound ~env ~bound dump in let gconsts = check_constants ~config ~enums ~consts:pconsts dump in let gwrote = gstructs = [] && gsigs = [] && gconsts = [] in if gwrote then begin let b = Buffer.create 65536 in Buffer.add_string b (banner h); List.iter (fun d -> Buffer.add_string b (decl_source d); Buffer.add_char b '\n') imported.decls; let ch = open_out out in output_string ch (Buffer.contents b); close_out ch end; { gwrote; gdecls = List.length imported.decls; gfns = List.length dump.fns; ghidden = imported.hidden; gstructs; gsigs; gconsts }